Injuries: Is BJJ Worth It?
One of my training partners dropped me a note about injuries. He was out hurt and knowing I am out with a pinched nerve, he was wondering if I thought BJJ was "worth it". It seems like people are injured quite a bit and there are a lot of activities like yoga, mountain biking, etc that seem much safer. Even though my injury was not bjj related, I thought it was a great question.
Overall I think BJJ falls in the middle of a safety spectrum. There are some things that are riskier, like football and some that are less risky, like golf. However, this type of analysis misses the point. The reality is that bjj chose me. I am not going to switch sports because something is safer. Now if I had another thing I loved as much, then the decision would be tougher, but this is it for me. I hate golf. So if we are not willing to quit the sport, how do we remain healthy?
In my experience, the biggest risk for injury is at the lower belts or in the extremely competitive levels. In the latter you are basically a pro athlete. You push very hard and when you redline your car, bad things happen. That is the ticket to entry. However, that is not most people. Most are training for fun, fitness, camaraderie and self-defense. In the typical bjj journey I see the most injuries at white and blue. If you get past those you are much safer. It is a lot like childhood. If someone is born today they may be expected to live to 74 but if you make it to 40, you will likely pass 80. Why? Because you didn't get drunk at 18 and fall off that cliff at Yosemite.
Ok, so why are white and blue dangerous. Lots of reasons. First is that you are at the mercy of most you roll with. This is both physically and mentally. Mentally when you are "newer" and someone ask to roll, you won't have the confidence to tell them you want to go easy or that you don't want to roll with them at all. Let's say you are an experienced white belt and some monster blue asks you to roll. You know this guy is going to smash you, you see it every day, but you just slap hands and take it. Why? You just think that is how it is. You have been told you need to "take your lumps". You don't have the confidence to express your fears or desires. Trust me, I have been there.
The other reason at the lower belts you have more risk is you are not as good. You are, by definition, not as controlled. Not as clear on what to do. So you not only can't get into dominant positions (where you are safer), but when you are in a bad spot, you flail using attributes. This means that you are injuring yourself. I have seen this as the key way people are hurt. They explode out of a position and into the doctors office.
I want to point out one last thing. Tapping. Everyone says tap early and people still don't. A big part of this is that the less experienced you are, the less sensitive you are - so you dont know when is the last final moment. Another reason is that the more resistance you give, the more your opponent pushes, and as discussed, less experienced people just won't have the control needed in those situations.
A big issue here the idea of waiting til you "should" tap. There is nothing wrong with tapping as soon as the guy grabs your arm. Now you can say you won't learn strong defense that way, or that you are short-changing your partner so they are not learning, etc. And you would be right! But I am not talking here about building great armbar defense. I am talking about the best way to keep healthy. Start here. Tap way way before you need to. When I roll with Dave he does this. Even though I think I am pretty controlled and have a purple belt, as soon as I get an arm (he gives me an arm), I take it SLOWLY and he taps FAST. He taps before it goes anywhere. Why? I am quite sure it is a defense mechanism. He could trust I will go slow, but too many don't. He can't remember every person and even then people are not always consistent. He can't take the risk.
I will also note that when I roll with people who take subs slowly, I get to know that. I like training with them. It is a safer roll. We should all take subs slow. Hey if they guy rips out of it, so what? He learned bad defense and you learned you should be tighter. If you can't hit a sub slow you can't hit it. Keep working the details.
Take a typical class. How can we be safe? Do the warm up, then the technique stuff. When time comes to drill, go very, very light. So light you get beat badly. Make it feel like a flowing session - but not choreographed. Then and only then will they go easy. This is a key point. You have to exaggerate how light you are going beyond what is expected. They need a sense of surprise to get it. Why? They are too used to people saying light and going hard. They need to see it in your actions.
On Rolling. Don't roll with anyone! Pick people carefully, or if no one "safe" is available, ask if they want to do reps on today's move. Or do solo drills - works for Galvao. If you do roll, work POSTURE. This means not exploding around from mount bottom, but protecting as long as you can. Or working guard and staying safe as long as possible. Do this only for positions and not subs though (as discussed).
Last point, Roy Dean and I chatted a few weeks back and he is into Ashtanga Yoga. He is convinced it helps his life and his game. I plan to start soon as well. I am quite certain that being fit and flexible will help avoid injury as well. Something to try.See you on the mat,
Paul